Human-Elephant confilict mitigation methods: A review of effectiveness and sustainability

Document Type: Original Article

Author

Department of Forest Resources, College of Agriculture and Life Sciences, Gyeongsang National University, Jinju

Abstract

Human-elephant conflicts (HEC) have resulted to substantial loss in livelihood and human lives, consequently, the affected communities retaliate by harming or killing the elephants. Thus, measures to mitigate HEC are imperative for the successful conservation of elephants, and to ensure the coexistence of the local population with these animals. Numerous HEC mitigating methods have been implemented. I reviewed 19 different HEC mitigation methods to assess their successes and failures, as well as their sustainability. Methods that required the regular presence of humans for their implementation and functionality tended to be very tedious and unsustainable since uptake of such methods would be very low. Also, methods that posed no threat to elephants were unsustainable as elephants become use to the methods. Approaches that are affected by weather conditions are unsustainable. Methods that were very expensive to implement are also unsustainable as the method would be abandoned when funding ends. However, electrical fencing was effective and sustainable since it doesn`t depend on the physical presence of human for it to prevent elephant destruction, especially when sustainable finance mechanism is assured to ensure monitoring and maintenance of the fence. Beehive fences are also very effective especially when colonization of the hives is assured, and this method is very sustainable as it is cost effective and honey from the hives could generate income for the population. Also methods aimed at habitat modification are sustainable since habitat improvement increases the comfort and resources elephants need to live in their habitat.

Keywords


AERP HEC project 2006. Mitigating human-elephant conflict in the Amboseli ecosystem, Kenya, Summary testing of deterrents year 1.

Alex C., Nick S., John M., Julius K., Angela M., Lucas M., Humphrey P.N., Jonathan K., Raphael O., Aloyce M., Nathan H., Suzanne P., David O. 2016. Scaling-up the use of chili fences for reducing human-elephant conflict across landscapes in Tanzania. Tropical Conservation Science 9 (2): 921-930.

Alfred P.K., Curtice R.G., Lee P. 2010. Elephant use and conflict leads to Tanzania’s first wildlife conservation corridor. Pachyderm 48: 57–66.

Barnes R.F.W. 1996. The conflict between humans and elephants in the central African forests. Mammal Review 26 (2-3): 67–80.

Blair J.A.S., Noor N.M. 1981. Conflict between the Malaysian elephant and agriculture. In: Nordian, M., Latiff, A., Mahani, M.C.,Tan, S.C. (Eds.), Conservation Inputs from Life Sciences. University of Kebangsaan, Malaysia, pp. 109–133.

Caitlin E.O., Timothy R., Matthew R., Lynette A.H. 2000. Living with the modern conservation paradigm: can agricultural communities co-exist with elephants? A five-year case study in East Caprivi. Namibia. Biological Conservation 93 (3): 381-391.

Charles S. 1996. Mitigation of human-elephant conflicts in Sri Lanka. Gajah 15.

Chelliah K., Kannan G., Kundu S., Abilash N., Madhusudan A., Baskaran N., Sukumar R. 2010. Testing the efficacy of a chilli–tobacco rope fence as a deterrent against crop-raiding elephants. Current Science 99 (9): 1239-1243.

Chiemelu N. 2004. At Whose Expense? Policy Formation in Wildlife Conservation and Human Conflict  in Kenya, Luce Undergraduate Environmental Fellows Program, Watson Institute for International Studies. 

Colin B., Matthew G., Suzannah D., Eibleis F. 2009. The influence of electric fences on large mammal movements in the Kilombero Valley, Tanzania. African Journal of Ecology 48 (1): 280–284.

Dublin T., McShane T., Newby J. 1997. Conserving Africa`s elephants: current issues and priorities for action, WWF, Gland, Switzerland. 28 p.

Ekobo A. 1997. Elephant problem in the mungo division, littoral province (Cameroon). Pachyderm 24: 53–63.

Ferrel V.O. 2002. Capsicum oleoresin as an elephant repellent: field trials in the communal lands of Zimbabwe. Journal of Wildlife Management 66(3): 674–677.

Ferrel V.O., Guy E.P. 2002. Community-based methods to reduce crop loss to elephants: experiments in the communal lands of Zimbabwe. Pachyderm 33: 32-38.

Graham M.D., Ochieng T. 2008. Uptake and performance of farm based measures for reducing crop raiding by elephants Loxodonta africana among small holder farms in Laikipia District, Kenya. Oryx 42 (1): 76–82.

Graham M.D., Gichohi N., Kamau F., Aike G., Craig B., Douglas-Hamilton I., Adams W. M. 2009. The Use of Electrified Fences to Reduce Human Elephant Conflict: A Case Study of the Ol Pejeta Conservancy, Laikipia District, Kenya, Working Paper 1, Laikipia Elephant Project, Nanyuki, Kenya.

Gunaratne L.H.P., Premarathne P.K. 2005. The effectiveness of electric fencing in mitigating human-elephant conflict in Sri Lanka, Research report; no. 2005-RR11, InternationalDevelopment Research Centre.

Hiten K.B., Soumen D., Anupam S., Amit S., Sanjay G., Tariq A., Dipankar G., Christy W.A. 2012. Use of Chilli Fences to Deter Asian Elephants - A Pilot Study. Gajah 36: 11-13.

Hoare R. 2001. Management implications of new research on problem elephants. Pachyderm 30: 44-48.

Ian W., Rudi A., Stuart L.P. 1998. Managing the elephants of Kruger National Park. Animal Conservation. 1 (2): 77–83.

Jackson T.P., Mosojane S., Ferreira S.M., Van Aarde R.J. 2008. Solution for elephant Loxodonta africana crop raiding in northern Botswana: moving away from symptomatic approaches. Oryx 42 (1): 83-91.

John H. 2006. Mitigation of human-elephant conflict in the Kavango-Zambezi Transfrontier Conservation Area through Community Based Problem Animal Control, with particular reference to the use of chilli peppers, Report prepared for Conservation International.

John K., Philip M., Patrick O., Patrick I.C. 2008. The performance of electric fences as elephant barriers in Amboseli, Kenya. South African Journal of Wildlife Research 38(1): 52–58.

Karidozo M., Osborn F.V. 2015. Community-based conflict mitigation trials: results of field tests of chili as elephant deterrent. Biodiversity and Endangered Species 3:144.

Li Z., Ning W. 2003. An initial study on habitat conservation of Asian elephant (Elephas maximus), with a focus on human elephant conflict in Simao, China. Biological Conservation 112 (3): 453–459.

Lucy E.K., Anna L., Iain D.H., Fritz V. 2009. Beehive fence deters crop-raiding elephants. African Journal of Ecology 47: 131–137.

Lucy E.K., Fredrick L., Hesron N., Emmanuel M., Iain D.H. 2017. Beehive fences as a multidimensional conflict-mitigation tool for farmers coexisting with elephants. Conservation Biology 31 (4): 743–752.

Lucy E.K., Iain D.H., Fritz V. 2007. African elephants run from the sound of disturbed bees. Current Biology 17 (19): 832-833.

Malima C., Hoare R., Blanc J. 2004. Systematic recording of human-elephant conflict: a case study in south-eastern Tanzania. Pachyderm 38: 29-38.

Mwakatobe A., Nyahongo J., Ntalwila J., Roskaft E. 2014. The impact of crop raiding by wild animalsin communities surrounding the Serengeti National Park, Tanzania. International  Journal  of  Biodiversity and Conservation 6(9): 637-646.

Naughton-Treves L. 1998. Predicting patterns of crop damage by wildlife around Kibale National Park, Uganda. Conservation Biology 12 (1): 156-168.

Noa P.W. 2009. Spatial behaviour of translocated African elephants (Loxodonta africana) in a novel environment: using behaviour to inform conservation actions. Behaviour 146: 1171-1192.

Omondi P., Bitok E., Kagiri J. 2004. Managing human–elephant conflicts: the Kenyan experience. Pachyderm 36: 80–86.

Osborn F.V., Rasmussen L.E.L. 1995. Evidence for the effectiveness of an oleoresin Capsicum aerosol as a repellant against wild elephants in Zimbabwe. Pachyderm 20: 55-64.

Osei-Owusu Y., Bakker L. 2008. Human-wildlife-conflict: elephant technical manual, Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations, Rome.

Parker G.E., Osborn F.V., Hoare R.E., Niskanen L.S. 2007. Human-elephant conflict mitigation: a training course for community-based approaches in Africa. Participant’s manual, Elephant Pepper Development Trust, Livingstone, Zambia and IUCN/SSC AfESG, Nairobi, Kenya.

Sébastien L.B., Mike L.G., Nolwenn D. 2015. Repelling elephants with a chilli pepper gas dispenser: field tests and practical use in Mozambique, Zambia and Zimbabwe from 2009 to 2013. Pachyderm 56.

Sébastien L.B., Russell T., Mike L., Onias N., Marc B., Hillary M. 2010. An easy-to-use capsicum delivery system for crop-raiding elephants in Zimbabwe: preliminary results of a field test in Hwange National Park. Pachyderm 47: 80-89.

Simon H., Donny G. 2009. Reducing human–elephant conflict: do chillies help deter elephants from entering crop fields? Fauna and Flora International. Oryx 44(1): 139–146

Sitati N.W. 2003. Human-elephant conflict in the Masai Mara dispersal areas of Transmara district, PhD Thesis, University of Kent, Canterbury, UK.

Stephenson P.J. 2004.  The  future  for  elephants in Africa. Pp 133-136  in Burgess N., D'Amico Hales J., Underwood E., Dinerstein

 E., Olson D., Itoua I., Schipper J., Ricketts T., Newman K. (eds.), Terrestrial Ecoregions of Africa and Madagascar: A Conservation Assessment, Island Press, Washington DC, USA.

Stuart L.P., Rudi J.A. 2001. Population control: African elephants and contraception. Nature 411: 766.

Tammy E., Davies S.W., Nandita H., Joydeep C., Dhruba D., Dave J., Alexandra Z. 2011. Effectiveness of intervention methods against crop-raiding elephants. Conservation Letters 4 (5): 346–354.

Tchamb M.N. 1995. The problem elephants of Kaele: a challenge for elephant conservation in northern Cameroon. Pachyderm 19: 26–32.

Thouless, C.R. and Sakwa, J. 1995. Shocking elephants: fences and crop raiders in Laikipia District, Kenya. Biological Conservation 72 (1): 99-107.

Wahed M.A., Ullah M.R., Irfanullah H.M. 2016. Human-Elephant Conflict Mitigation Measures: Lessons from Bangladesh. IUCN, Bangladesh Country Office, Dhaka, Bangladesh. 30 pp.

Whyte I. 1993. The movement patterns of elephants in the Kruger National Park in response to culling and environmental stimuli. Pachyderm 16: 72-80. Wright S. 1943. Isolation by distance. Genetics 28(2): 114–138.